• Silencers - Which One is the Quietest and Best???

      Guide to Choosing a Silencer for an Airgun

      Hi I thought after seeing so many adverts and threads regarding silencers which one is the best which one is the quietest? I decided to do this guide for help to newbies and even gun guru's.

      No one silencer is the best or the quietest that is down to what your gun likes best. My advice is to ask your local gunshop what silencers they stock and can you test one on your gun to hear the sound. Remember if dry firing a pcp it will be even quieter when shooting a pellet through it plus indoors you will have echo. You will probably be more than likely buying a silencer for sole purpose of hunting so the rabbit doesn't bolt upon any instant sound. In the field the echo in a shop won't be heard so remember this.

      There are that many available inc independent engineering companies making them inc several on here. I have tested all versions on all main brands. The main branded silencers I would say are

      Hogan Decimeter
      Weihrauch
      Sak
      Swift
      Parker Hale
      Daystate Airstream
      Logun CCFC
      FX Whisper
      Air Arms
      Milbro Huggett
      Theoben Vortex

      General Opinions - Other Gun Owners
      You are best to ask other owners of your gun what they are using and see whats the general opinion. A gunshop may just sell you one they have in stock. A decent gunshop will carry stock of several brands so you can test. My testing I have found the Hogan Decimeter overall to be very quiet on most brands inc BSA, Webley, Air Arms, FX, Weihrauch, Theoben, Logun and many more. I would also recommend silencers from UK Neil I have tried several and he produces a very quiet version.

      Re-zero Scope - New Silencer
      You will need to rezero your scope every time you change your silencer and I recommend if using a 1/2 unf threaded silencer that it is removed if put in a gun bag. There is a high chance the gun bag is stored upright and gunbag is often squeezed into the boot or back seats of a car. The silencer often gets knocked thus knocking your barrel out a few degrees. If you don't want to remove your silencer every time invest in a hard plastic case shich will prevent this happening.

      Silencer adaptors - I'm not a big fan of these as in my expeirance they sometimes will get knocked a few degrees thus possible clipping inside your silencer. This will cause accuracy issues if hunting you will get knocks here and there so it will happen. Buy a dedicated silencer that fits over the barrel is better unless your gun barrel is threaded for 1/2 unf then choose one of those.

      Spring Airguns - Silencers
      Now this is a big debate is it worth putting a silencer on a spring airgun. Well, in my opinion yes and no! If its loud its probably better spending money on tuning the gun to make it smoother and less recoil thus quieter action. On cheap springuns like SMK, Edgar Brothers, Gamo etc It will remove some decibels but nothing major to the human ear. Now to the rabbit you are hoping to have for dinner it will help slightly giving you an advantage in getting your stew! I tested the new slip on Weihrauch silencer on a HW77 and was totally amazed how effective it was it virtually reduced the sound to nothing. High end springers like TX200, Prosport and the Weihrauch & Diana family they will be effective even more so when the guns have been tuned. Lower budget spring guns you will get a slight reduction but nothing dramatic. A budget springer its worth tuning to make it quieter instead of spending £40 plus on a silencer that isn't going to make a high improvement.

      Well hope that helps its all my own opinon its not the gospel. I may be right - I may be wrong but as stated I have been shooting along time and have and own alot of airguns. All the very best - welcome to AGF
      Comments 28 Comments
      1. tatsumi's Avatar
        tatsumi -
        Great Write up Jay Jay.
        I too have found that some gun shops sell what they have a good deal on at the time and there's no better way than going through the brands to find the right one for your rifle so shop around and take your time and ask other owners what they use before you spend your money.
      1. mattw975's Avatar
        mattw975 -
        Good write up, would have been better if MWSS units were mentioned by the man they call mattw975 (rather than mentioning that UK guy who resides on the Darkside lol !!).

        Cheers,

        Matt

        Quote Originally Posted by tatsumi View Post
        Great Write up Jay Jay.
        I too have found that some gun shops sell what they have a good deal on at the time and there's no better way than going through the brands to find the right one for your rifle so shop around and take your time and ask other owners what they use before you spend your money.
      1. Jay Jay's Avatar
        Jay Jay -
        Matt send me a silencer 1/2 unf I'll do some tests I'll send it back after.
      1. weihrauch hw's Avatar
        weihrauch hw -
        what about twink silencers?? I heard they were as good or better than weihrauch!
        And i can vouch for mattw, his silencers are great
      1. hun73r666's Avatar
        hun73r666 -
        I got a Twink, and its the dogs nob! As good if not better than the HW!
      1. sniper22's Avatar
        sniper22 -
        any test on any silencer will give different results on different guns at different locations and different atmospheric conditions. a good silencer on my rifle mifght not be as good on yours. also different results at a further distance.
        the noise may be quieter on silencer "A" than "B" but the tone may be different and be audiable to your quarry in yourr sights.
        its impossible to say silencer "X" is better than anything else.
      1. Jay Jay's Avatar
        Jay Jay -
        Quote Originally Posted by sniper22 View Post
        any test on any silencer will give different results on different guns at different locations and different atmospheric conditions. a good silencer on my rifle mifght not be as good on yours. also different results at a further distance.
        the noise may be quieter on silencer "A" than "B" but the tone may be different and be audiable to your quarry in yourr sights.
        its impossible to say silencer "X" is better than anything else.
        hi that is already covered.

        I am happy to conduct tests on any other silencer i.e Twink/Matty version - Twink already make the Daystate silencers but i am basing my guide on most popular ones for sale in gunshops.

        Im more than happy to mention any other silencers but would like to conduct tests for personal satisfaction.
      1. tatsumi's Avatar
        tatsumi -
        Matt my appoligies if i caused any disrespect there. I hold yours in high regard, indeed over the HW model(from experiance) and my comments were purly on the write up in general
      1. Jay Jay's Avatar
        Jay Jay -
        By NOT mentioning other brands I am not saying they are inferior or poor. I just don't know of them or have used or seen them. Guide is based on top selling and most prominent sold I visit alot of gunshops and on my list these are one's I see regularly in stock. I welcome other brands to be sent for testing by me I'll post back no problems I own alot of guns so will test on all major brands inc AA, BSA, Falcon, Weihrauch, Theoben, Daystate, Webley, Gunpower, Brocock and others.
      1. mattw975's Avatar
        mattw975 -
        No problem Tats, no offence taken mate
      1. jonnyrapid7's Avatar
        jonnyrapid7 -
        Quote Originally Posted by Jay Jay View Post
        By NOT mentioning other brands I am not saying they are inferior or poor. I just don't know of them or have used or seen them. Guide is based on top selling and most prominent sold I visit alot of gunshops and on my list these are one's I see regularly in stock. I welcome other brands to be sent for testing by me I'll post back no problems I own alot of guns so will test on all major brands inc AA, BSA, Falcon, Weihrauch, Theoben, Daystate, Webley, Gunpower, Brocock and others.

        Let me no on the theoben mate, my mates s16 is quieter than my rapid.
      1. Jay Jay's Avatar
        Jay Jay -
        Well I personally didn't rate the vortex silencer on tests on several rapids I owned. I found the sak silencer to be great but mattw on here is getting glowing reports. I still have my test option open for a 1/2 unf to be sent. Chance here to really see how good they are!
      1. datadave's Avatar
        datadave -
        Thanks for a useful insight, Jay Jay. To pass on my own limited experience: I have two Weihrauch silencers - one on my 177 Brocock Contour which is extremely effective and one on my tuned 177 HW95, which I would rate as 'good' but not as effective as on the Brocock. I've also tried it on the Ole Lady's 177 S200 Mk II - again, extremely effective. This seems to bear out your findings that silencers are most effective on PCP's. Haven't yet tried it on C02 - I'll give it a whirl on my TH78D and see how it performs. The Ole Lady currently has what I think is a Webley silencer on her S200 - which is less effective than the Weihrauch but still considerably reduces the muzzle 'crack' - although as she was given the silencer, she's not sure of the make.Cheers Datadaved
      1. ME AND MY GUNS's Avatar
        ME AND MY GUNS -
        Parker hale MM1 ugly heavy but very effective
      1. ..::Mr Sci::..'s Avatar
        ..::Mr Sci::.. -
        what silencer would you suggest for a Remington genisis??
      1. Jay Jay's Avatar
        Jay Jay -
        Not sure?


        ---
        - Sent from somewhere on this planet on some electronic device.
      1. secretagentmole's Avatar
        secretagentmole -
        The Twink is better than the HW, apart from use on the HW100, then the HW silencer really is the mutts! HW have obviously tuned the silencer to work best on their premier rifle. No surprise there, however on other air rifles you will find that the Twink will outperform the HW!
      1. hun73r666's Avatar
        hun73r666 -
        Quote Originally Posted by secretagentmole View Post
        The Twink is better than the HW, apart from use on the HW100, then the HW silencer really is the mutts! HW have obviously tuned the silencer to work best on their premier rifle. No surprise there, however on other air rifles you will find that the Twink will outperform the HW!
        I agree mate that the Twink mkII is the dogs! I have one on my AA S410. I also have a HW silencer but this is on my brocock pistol and does not fit my rifle so cant compare. However, the HW is very very silent on a brocock pistol.
      1. mick 1986's Avatar
        mick 1986 -
        What are the internals of the twink like??
      1. hun73r666's Avatar
        hun73r666 -
        To be honest mick I have no idea. I have not opened one up. I would be interested to know if they can be used on rimfire though, and I guess the internals would dictate that.